I think this article really brings to light a number of useful and necessary points.
One, is just the waste of life that occurs at these animal testing facilities. For years, Yerkes has been watched and documented as a facility that simply finds totally irrelevant “tests” on non-human primates to perform that amount to nothing.
From this, we see the second point: that is, that these tests cannot even be guarantee that any non-human tests will be relevant. So, this proposal by Yerkes to use Sooty Mangabeys just because they really have nothing else to do with them (except free them of course) is just misleading and irresponsible. So, for those who don’t care at all about other species, maybe they care about wasted resources. I’ve pulled four paragraphs from the article below to sum up the points.
“Recently, Yerkes researchers proposed a novel solution: The primate center will help conserve sooties in the wild in exchange for permission to do AIDS-related research on them here.
Chimpanzees were once deemed promising for HIV research, but they don't get sick from HIV. Sooties may be no better than chimps, said Theodora Capaldo, president of the New England Anti-Vivisection Society, one of the nation's oldest groups opposing animal experimentation.
"The thing that concerns me is they (Yerkes officials) have a 'product' - an abundance of monkeys - that they want to do something with, and now they're going to find something to do with them. But that's backwards thinking, the idea that availability drives inquiry," she said.
Yerkes officials say it's hard to predict results of future research, but sooties differ from chimps in several ways, including the amount of virus they naturally carry.”
Article:
SEATTLE POST-INTELLIGENCER
Sunday, April 9, 2006 • Last updated 7:58 p.m. PT
Sooty mangabeys at heart of research fight
http://seattlepi.nwsource.com/national/1501AP_
Research_Monkeys.html
By MIKE STOBBE
ASSOCIATED PRESS WRITER
ATLANTA -- As monkeys go, sooty mangabeys aren't cute.
Big-fanged, gray and hairy, they simply stare when threatened. Few zoos stock them. Some animal rights advocates can't even spell the species' name.
Nevertheless, the sooties are at the center of a precedent-setting debate over whether researchers should be allowed to experiment on an endangered species.
Scientists at the Yerkes National Primate Research Center in Atlanta have nurtured a group of these primates for decades. But after Yerkes started the colony, federal officials listed sooties as endangered.
The result: Yerkes has the world's largest collection of captive sooties, but with little hope of scientific benefit.
"We don't need them around just to look at them. We're not a zoo," said Thomas Gordon, Yerkes' associate director for scientific programs.
Recently, Yerkes researchers proposed a novel solution: The primate center will help conserve sooties in the wild in exchange for permission to do AIDS-related research on them here.
Such a trade-off has never before been permitted, said Timothy Van Norman, chief of the international permits branch at the U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service. "This is new territory," he said.
Yerkes officials are hopeful. Animal rights activists are horrified.
"It's a deal with the devil," said Rachel Weiss, president of Laboratory Primate Advocacy Group, a Georgia-based animal rights organization.
Yerkes - part of Emory University - is one of eight federally funded national primate research centers. Its scientific contributions include new understanding of monkey and chimp behavior and development of an experimental AIDS vaccine.
It has about 3,600 primates at a 25-acre campus in Atlanta and a 117-acre field station in nearby Lawrenceville.
Yerkes' colony of sooty mangabeys was started in the late 1960s, when the center picked up about 30, some from Kansas City's zoo. The colony grew, and now numbers about 230.
It would be larger, but the Yerkes staff segregate males from females and give females Norplant-like birth control pellets. The center spends roughly $170,000 each year for sooty care-taking, and is out of space to house any more.
In 1988, U.S. Fish & Wildlife listed sooties as endangered. That means Yerkes may not do invasive research, such as a biopsy, unless it benefits the species.
"We can't even take a blood sample for research purposes," complained Preston Marx, a researcher at Tulane University, which also has a sooty colony.
In the 1990s, researchers learned sooties are natural carriers of a monkey-form of the AIDS virus. Other types of monkeys get sick from the virus. Sooties don't. Researchers say if they can learn why sooties stay healthy, it may lead to new weapons against human HIV.
To do that, scientists want to expose the monkeys to different viruses and do biopsies or other invasive research.
For a decade, Yerkes has been asking the government to drop sooties from the endangered list or consider other ways to allow research.
They saw an opportunity when Van Norman, Fish & Wildlife's chief of international permits, suggested the agency might grant the right to research in exchange for supporting conservation of the monkeys in the wild.
Last year, Yerkes began providing up to $30,000 a year to support primatologist Scott McGraw's field-based conservation and research of sooties in the Tai National Park Reserve in Ivory Coast, West Africa.
In July, the center wrote Fish & Wildlife seeking the right to conduct research on the Yerkes sooties "given our contribution to sooty mangabey conservation."
The request is under review, Fish & Wildlife officials said.
The proposal is not completely novel - it echoes the agency's "safe harbor" policy. That allows landowners the prospect of future development of land that serves as habitat for threatened or endangered animals, as long as the animals' original population doesn't fall and other standards are met.
But animal rights advocates are uncomfortable applying such a trade-off to lab animals.
Sooties live in large pens at the Yerkes field station, with some freedom to roam and socialize. But being a research monkey is a "terrible life" that often involves indoor caging and pain, said Weiss, who was a Yerkes animal care technician in the mid-1990s.
"It's a tough call when you talk about conservation of a species versus protecting individuals. But we have to remember individuals comprise a species," she said.
Animal rights groups have criticized Yerkes before. They point to the death of a chimp in 2004. After that happened, a federal inspection of monkey carrier cages led to a fine for lack of proper ventilation.
Also, they argue, experimentation with sooties may not be fruitful.
Chimpanzees were once deemed promising for HIV research, but they don't get sick from HIV. Sooties may be no better than chimps, said Theodora Capaldo, president of the New England Anti-Vivisection Society, one of the nation's oldest groups opposing animal experimentation.
"The thing that concerns me is they (Yerkes officials) have a 'product' - an abundance of monkeys - that they want to do something with, and now they're going to find something to do with them. But that's backwards thinking, the idea that availability drives inquiry," she said.
Yerkes officials say it's hard to predict results of future research, but sooties differ from chimps in several ways, including the amount of virus they naturally carry.
"The sense from the scientists is we need now to move to the next level," Gordon said.
GEARI (the Group for the Education of Animal - Related Issues) is a non-profit educational group dedicated to assisting you in your search for information on animal rights-related issues, the environment and human health. Your reference source for animal rights information. Visit us at our web site at http://www.geari.org. Follow us on Facebook and Twitter, or Syndicate us via RSS.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Search for More Content
Custom Search
Past Articles
-
▼
2006
(726)
-
▼
April
(68)
- Spain's Governing Party Promoting a Controversial ...
- Group In Oregon Wants Schumacher Fur Store To Labe...
- National Animal-Rights Group Urges Counseling For ...
- Judge in NJ Fines Activists Protesting the New Jer...
- Simple Form to Let Representatives Know You Suppor...
- Chicago Bans Sale of Foie Gras in Restaurants: Wh...
- Sickos in Williams Township in NJ Kill Two Baby Go...
- In Effort To Encourage Greater Care Of Companion A...
- Commentary: Protesters Against Animal Experimentat...
- Turkeys at a Farm in the UK Were Thrown In the Air...
- Group Has Filed Notice That it Will Sue The Minnes...
- Last Chance for Animals to Push for Congress to Pa...
- 16 Year Old Girl Posts Video of Herself Abusing Ca...
- Drug Testing Giant Covance Plans to Build Vivisect...
- New Group Seeks Amnesty and Restitution for Chimpa...
- Removed From the Jungle and Smuggled Into Thailand...
- Utah Settles a Lawsuit Filed by Two Animal-Rights ...
- Even in Tasmania, Activists Fight to Expose Cruelt...
- Dog Eating Will Stay Illegal In The Philippines
- Advocates Lobby Against End To Sunday Hunting Ban ...
- Reward Offered For Info In Brutal Dog Abuse Case i...
- Animal Rights Groups Seek Probe Into Lion Cub's De...
- In the Town of Collierville, TN, Puppy Mutilated, ...
- Louisiana's Proposed Pet Evacuation Bill, Passed T...
- Louisiana's Proposed Pet Evacuation Bill - Senate ...
- Bennie Thompson: This Earth Day, Let’s Make Enviro...
- The Sierra Club Creates Contest to Finance a Sport...
- Even Though Chinese Eat Less Civets due to SARS, t...
- When Other Animals Suffer, So Do We: Washington Po...
- Pro-Hunting Japanese Seize Control Of Whaling Comm...
- HSUS Ends it’s Documentation for this Year of the ...
- Another Sell Out: Nestlé Looks Set To Swallow Up ...
- Brutal Canadians Laugh at the Rules and Exceed Kil...
- In Canada, the Harassment Continues: Those who Cam...
- Postal Workers Have Reports Of Baby Chicks Dying I...
- India's Tigers Are Vanishing at an Alarming Rate: ...
- Puppies Being Smuggled Out of Mexico to be Sold At...
- Group Decides To Withdraw Activities In Romania Fo...
- Campaign Against the Cruelty of Kentucky Fried Chi...
- Residents in the Eastern Quebec in Canada Resort t...
- Sickening Videos of Pigs Being Stunned With Taser ...
- How You Can Help Pass The Louisiana Pet Evacuation...
- New Video Game for Play Station Turns Table on Ani...
- Wacko Wacks Out and Eats Puppy
- In Scotland, Dog Pulling as Cruel as Dog Fighting ...
- Brutal Canadians to Begin Second Leg of Baby Seal ...
- Maine Fully Enacts Bill To Allow Judges To Include...
- Kentucky Legislature Votes To Make Illegal The Pra...
- ASPCA Leads in a Lawsuit against Ringling Brothers...
- Oxford University Seeks to Deny Free Speech and Fr...
- Even though Yerkes Cannot Prove that HIV Tests Wou...
- Believe it or Not, Mattel Creates a “Bullfighting ...
- The Kenya Wildlife Service Says it Has Broken Up a...
- Cathy Kangas of PRAI Beauty Offers Canadian Govt. ...
- Citizens of Louisiana Will Have March Declaring Ne...
- After Intimidation and Pressure by Canadian Govern...
- USDA Has Fined Drug-Testing Company Covance, After...
- Animal Rights Groups Honors Police for Saving Moose
- Maine's Governor Signs Bill That Allows Animals To...
- Scientists Cause Additional Suffering to Examine S...
- National Park Service in Point Reyes, California P...
- Humane Society of the United States Denied Permit ...
- Costco Removes Seal Oil Capsules From Their St. Jo...
- Two Hindu Organizations Are Supporting A Hare Kris...
- Somali Animal Rights Community Looks to Save Many ...
- Pictures of Dogs and Cats Who Were Victims of Hurr...
- Canadian Government Attempts to Hide the Brutal Tr...
- Misleading "Animal Care Certified" Logo Found on E...
-
▼
April
(68)
No comments:
Post a Comment