An excellent commentary. Though is written in the UK in response to the draconian Oxford University, it really applies to rational activists everywhere. And note that this person isn’t some off the wall wacko as they’d like to say, she’s a person who actually graduated from Oxford and is now returning her degree.
Of course though, in the game of politics, the huge political Oxford and those like it will always want to lie and make up childlike names to belittle the other side.
Article:
We're not terrorists, and we're not against progress
http://www.guardian.co.uk/
Protesters against animal experimentation should not be caricatured as anti-science, says Sharon Howe
Friday March 10, 2006
The Guardian
Despite his Orwellian imagery, Timothy Garton Ash's stereotypical presentation of an enlightened pro-vivisection elite versus an ignorant and destructive bunch of "antis" is hardly consistent with his declared belief in the "pursuit of truth and the defence of reason" (We must stand up to the creeping tyranny of the group veto, March 2). These principles are genuinely close to my heart. That's why I am passionately opposed to animal experimentation. And that's why I am returning my first-class Oxford degree as a personal protest against the university's new biomedical research centre.
Yes, animal testing has always gone on at Oxford. But the university has also produced some eminent critics of animal-based research: John Ruskin resigned his position as professor of literature the day after vivisection was introduced.
It is ironic that Garton Ash should centre his argument on the importance of free speech, as it is this vital privilege which is being eroded by the injunction imposed upon those who wish to exercise their right to peaceful protest - they are now allowed to voice their views outside the college only between 1pm and 5pm on Thursdays.
It may make for better headlines to portray anti-vivisectionists as terrorists bent on obstructing medical progress, but it couldn't be further from the truth. The vast majority are compassionate individuals who find it an outrage that millions of pounds of taxpayers' money is wasted on outdated and misleading animal-based research, while doctors at Oxford's own Radcliffe Infirmary are crying out for funds to invest in human-based stroke research.
The time has come for a proper, reasoned debate: to get away from the specious "dog or child" dilemma with which pro-vivisectionists seek to play on our fears. The Home Office itself admitted that it "has not commissioned or evaluated any formal research on the efficacy of animal experiments".
Despite the fact that human brains can now be studied non-invasively using hi-tech scanners, diseases such as Parkinson's - for which I am particularly keen to see a cure as I watch my own mother suffer from its debilitating effects - are still being painfully and artificially induced in monkeys who do not naturally develop them.
But the tide of public opinion is changing. Plans for a similar animal lab at Cambridge were abandoned after the university failed to prove a "national need" at a public planning meeting. In 2002, MEPs voted for a complete review of the use of all primates in experiments. And there has been strong support among MPs for an Early Day Motion calling for an independent scientific evaluation of the clinical relevance of animal testing - support shared by 83% of GPs, according to a survey by Europeans for Medical Progress.
The technology to achieve change already exists - it is institutional inertia and vested interests that are holding back progress. Here is the perfect opportunity to move forward and develop a centre of excellence for cutting-edge, non-animal research which would only enhance Oxford's reputation as a seat of human progress. Then I too could regain my pride in being associated with it.
Sharon Howe is a graduate of Oxford university sharon@int-trans.eclipse.co.uk
GEARI (the Group for the Education of Animal - Related Issues) is a non-profit educational group dedicated to assisting you in your search for information on animal rights-related issues, the environment and human health. Your reference source for animal rights information. Visit us at our web site at http://www.geari.org. Follow us on Facebook and Twitter, or Syndicate us via RSS.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Search for More Content
Custom Search
Past Articles
-
▼
2006
(726)
-
▼
April
(68)
- Spain's Governing Party Promoting a Controversial ...
- Group In Oregon Wants Schumacher Fur Store To Labe...
- National Animal-Rights Group Urges Counseling For ...
- Judge in NJ Fines Activists Protesting the New Jer...
- Simple Form to Let Representatives Know You Suppor...
- Chicago Bans Sale of Foie Gras in Restaurants: Wh...
- Sickos in Williams Township in NJ Kill Two Baby Go...
- In Effort To Encourage Greater Care Of Companion A...
- Commentary: Protesters Against Animal Experimentat...
- Turkeys at a Farm in the UK Were Thrown In the Air...
- Group Has Filed Notice That it Will Sue The Minnes...
- Last Chance for Animals to Push for Congress to Pa...
- 16 Year Old Girl Posts Video of Herself Abusing Ca...
- Drug Testing Giant Covance Plans to Build Vivisect...
- New Group Seeks Amnesty and Restitution for Chimpa...
- Removed From the Jungle and Smuggled Into Thailand...
- Utah Settles a Lawsuit Filed by Two Animal-Rights ...
- Even in Tasmania, Activists Fight to Expose Cruelt...
- Dog Eating Will Stay Illegal In The Philippines
- Advocates Lobby Against End To Sunday Hunting Ban ...
- Reward Offered For Info In Brutal Dog Abuse Case i...
- Animal Rights Groups Seek Probe Into Lion Cub's De...
- In the Town of Collierville, TN, Puppy Mutilated, ...
- Louisiana's Proposed Pet Evacuation Bill, Passed T...
- Louisiana's Proposed Pet Evacuation Bill - Senate ...
- Bennie Thompson: This Earth Day, Let’s Make Enviro...
- The Sierra Club Creates Contest to Finance a Sport...
- Even Though Chinese Eat Less Civets due to SARS, t...
- When Other Animals Suffer, So Do We: Washington Po...
- Pro-Hunting Japanese Seize Control Of Whaling Comm...
- HSUS Ends it’s Documentation for this Year of the ...
- Another Sell Out: Nestlé Looks Set To Swallow Up ...
- Brutal Canadians Laugh at the Rules and Exceed Kil...
- In Canada, the Harassment Continues: Those who Cam...
- Postal Workers Have Reports Of Baby Chicks Dying I...
- India's Tigers Are Vanishing at an Alarming Rate: ...
- Puppies Being Smuggled Out of Mexico to be Sold At...
- Group Decides To Withdraw Activities In Romania Fo...
- Campaign Against the Cruelty of Kentucky Fried Chi...
- Residents in the Eastern Quebec in Canada Resort t...
- Sickening Videos of Pigs Being Stunned With Taser ...
- How You Can Help Pass The Louisiana Pet Evacuation...
- New Video Game for Play Station Turns Table on Ani...
- Wacko Wacks Out and Eats Puppy
- In Scotland, Dog Pulling as Cruel as Dog Fighting ...
- Brutal Canadians to Begin Second Leg of Baby Seal ...
- Maine Fully Enacts Bill To Allow Judges To Include...
- Kentucky Legislature Votes To Make Illegal The Pra...
- ASPCA Leads in a Lawsuit against Ringling Brothers...
- Oxford University Seeks to Deny Free Speech and Fr...
- Even though Yerkes Cannot Prove that HIV Tests Wou...
- Believe it or Not, Mattel Creates a “Bullfighting ...
- The Kenya Wildlife Service Says it Has Broken Up a...
- Cathy Kangas of PRAI Beauty Offers Canadian Govt. ...
- Citizens of Louisiana Will Have March Declaring Ne...
- After Intimidation and Pressure by Canadian Govern...
- USDA Has Fined Drug-Testing Company Covance, After...
- Animal Rights Groups Honors Police for Saving Moose
- Maine's Governor Signs Bill That Allows Animals To...
- Scientists Cause Additional Suffering to Examine S...
- National Park Service in Point Reyes, California P...
- Humane Society of the United States Denied Permit ...
- Costco Removes Seal Oil Capsules From Their St. Jo...
- Two Hindu Organizations Are Supporting A Hare Kris...
- Somali Animal Rights Community Looks to Save Many ...
- Pictures of Dogs and Cats Who Were Victims of Hurr...
- Canadian Government Attempts to Hide the Brutal Tr...
- Misleading "Animal Care Certified" Logo Found on E...
-
▼
April
(68)
No comments:
Post a Comment