This is good reading for everyone. Not only does the author do a good job of breaking down the relations of humans to our primate cousins, he also lays out the logic behind Spain’s amazing move.
He also brings attention to the Great Ape Project, a group dedicated to pushing forth these necessary changes. You can learn more at: http://www.greatapeproject.org/
Article:
Spain Going Ape for Animal Rights
http://www.progress.org/2006/fold459.htm
Fred Foldvary
by Fred E. Foldvary, Senior Editor
The Great Ape Project, based in a Seattle, Washington, has campaigned for a "community of equals" in which all the great apes would have the legal rights to life, freedom, and protection from torture. Now the ruling coalition in Spain is proposing to apply this idea in a law that would recognize the moral rights of great apes as legal persons.
The argument that all the great apes have the same moral rights as human beings rests on the biological connection that human beings have to the other apes, and to the relatively high intelligence shown by non-human apes. Human beings, apes, monkeys, and lemurs belong to the primate order of mammals. Human beings are of the Hominoidea superfamily of primates, which is composed of two families, Hylobatidae (gibbons, the lesser apes), and Hominidae, the great apes.
The great apes include gorillas, chimpanzees, orangutans, and homo sapiens, human beings. According to current biological taxonomy, Hominidae are currently classed into two subfamilies, Homininae (human beings and gorillas) and Ponginae (orangutans). Homininae are divided into two tribes, Hominini and Gorillini (gorillas). Hominini are classed in two genera, the genus Pan with chimpanzees, and the genus Homo with human beings.
So we can see that human beings are very closely related especially to chimpanzees, and also kin to gorillas. Homininae are highly intelligent, some gorillas having learned to speak in sign language, and chimpanzees being observed to use tools and to have a learned culture. The evidence indicates that the non-human great apes use reason and choose their action to a great extent. Moral logic therefore concludes that killing to inflicting pain on great apes imposes a great amount of harm on them, which implies that all great apes have moral rights. Spain would be well justified to become the first country to legally recognize the moral rights of great apes.
The proposal, led by Francisco Garrido, a member of the Green party, would legally replace the "ownership" of great apes with "moral guardianship," similar to the treatment of children and people in comas. Under that law, the initiation of force against a great ape, such killing, inflicting unnecessary pain, taking a baby away from its family, or enslavement (such as confining them in a cage), would be a crime, although zoos could continue to keep them if moving them elsewhere would be more harmful.
Other countries have already enacted some legal recognition of moral rights for apes. New Zealand's animal welfare act prescribes that research and testing using a great ape requires that the expected benefits be greater than the harm to the apes, and Great Britain has banned medical experimentation on great apes.
Opposition to the Spanish proposal has been voice by prominent Catholics, who say that human embryos would have less legal protection than the designated animals. Spanish members of Amnesty International have pointed out that the moral rights of many human beings are not yet protected, and should have priority.
But these are not valid arguments against the legal recognition of the moral rights of the great apes. One wrong does not justify another wrong. Those opposed to the legal protection of apes against harm need to confront the argument in favor of moral rights for apes. There is nothing in natural moral law that specifically privileges human beings as morally superior. The moral rights of human beings derives from their high degree, as a species, of intelligence and sentience, and if other species, such as chimpanzees and dolphins, exhibit such characteristics, then by natural moral law, they have the same level of moral rights.
The degree of reasoning capacity held by non-human apes, along with other animals such as dolphins, is a matter of biological evidence. It seems to me that we should give these animals the benefit of the doubt, and if we err, it should be on the side of their having moral rights.
So, bravo to Spain for leading the way. If the great apes are accorded more respect, then this would help the world to give human beings also greater protection for their human rights. If all the great apes are accorded legal protection against harm, we will then have to speak not of just human rights, but Hominidae rights. We could call all the great apes "sapiens" and refer to sapient rights. The motto could then be: equal rights for all sapiens; privileges for none!
GEARI (the Group for the Education of Animal - Related Issues) is a non-profit educational group dedicated to assisting you in your search for information on animal rights-related issues, the environment and human health. Your reference source for animal rights information. Visit us at our web site at http://www.geari.org. Follow us on Facebook and Twitter, or Syndicate us via RSS.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Search for More Content
Custom Search
Past Articles
-
▼
2006
(726)
-
▼
June
(70)
- Farm Animal Stewardship Purchasing Act Would Requi...
- Site Set Up to Support Lost and Found Companion “P...
- Interesting New Site Takes a Look at the Truth Beh...
- Teen Will Spend Two Weeks Chained To a Doghouse to...
- Group Releases List of Precautions and Steps to Ta...
- American Horse Slaughter Prevention Act: Stop Hor...
- Excellent Summation of Laws Either Enacted or Curr...
- Pets as Companions: Words Mean A Lot: Changing the...
- Kangaroo Island Near Australia Takes on Feral Cat ...
- Designer Dogs: Big Price tags and Big Health Prob...
- Hawaii Makes Major Steps and Signs into Law Two La...
- Beluga Sturgeon Hearty to Have Survived from Prehi...
- For Two And A Half Thousand Dollars, Wellington Zo...
- For First Time in Decades, Japan and Its Pro-Whali...
- Man Will Start a Eight-Day Cycle to Raise as Much ...
- Jane Goodall and Researchers Send Letter to Federa...
- Group Asks Merriam-Webster to Rewrite Definition o...
- Groups Seek to Ban Foie Gras Production in New Yor...
- The Illegal Trade of Animal Parts Goes On: Seven A...
- Test Tube or Lab-Grown Meat Nears Dinner Table: B...
- South Africa's Proposals to Clamp Down On "Canned ...
- Britain Heads Towards Ban of Bearskin Hats Worn By...
- DVD ''Hood Fights, Vol. 2, The Art Of The Pit'', W...
- Children Who Live or Attend School Near Large-Scal...
- Group Asks That Federal Authorities Investigate th...
- Whole Foods and Safeway Suspend the Selling of Liv...
- Who Belongs In The Zoo? It May Be That Some Anima...
- In China, Protest Shuts Down Restaurant Serving Ca...
- Whole Foods Bans Sale of Live Lobsters
- In South Africa, Foreign Jet Set Hunters Kill More...
- Disasters Boost Charitable Giving in US, Including...
- Commercial Whaling May Once Again Continue: Vote a...
- Independent Journalist Asserts Constitutional Righ...
- Activists Confront Beyonce Knowles About Her Love ...
- Secure the Release of a Number of Chimpanzee Elde...
- An In-depth Look at Horse Slaughter: Why Is It Oc...
- Animal Rights Group Holds Los Angeles Mayor Antoni...
- A Nice Summation of How Those Pretty Host Finches,...
- Tropical Storm Alberto Makes Landfall / NOLA Pet E...
- The National Lawyers Guild Condemns FBI’s Operatio...
- The Ugliness and Truth of Horseracing Exposed: Un...
- On Eve of International Whaling Commission Meeting...
- Teen Girls Who Filmed Themselves on MySpace.Com Ki...
- Due to Japan’s Sneaky Tactics, Pro-Whaling Nations...
- The Hain Celestial Group Acquires the Assets of th...
- Group Urges India's Fruit Exporters to Donate Mang...
- Activists Have Been Banned from Demonstrating Wher...
- Actions to Expose Cruelty of Zoos in the Philippin...
- Grocery Chain Safeway Wins Praise for Moving Towar...
- Another Premature and Unnatural Elephant Death in ...
- Editorial: Why it’s A Common Sense Good Move That...
- Playing God: Some Chickens Genetically Engineered ...
- New Study: Some Species of Animals are Already Cha...
- Whale and Dolphin News
- Polo Ralph Lauren Is Eliminating Fur from All of I...
- Exposed: Principal Buyer of Canadian Dead Baby Sea...
- Whores to Business and Hunting the Florida Fish an...
- Ask For Maximum Sentence for Premeditated Dog Killers
- HSUS Has Filed a Notice of Intent to Sue Hudson Va...
- Protesters Have Frustrated an Attempt to Transport...
- Asia/ Film Reveals the Drama of Tibet's Poacher War
- Group Sues Woodland Park Zoo Over Treatment of Ele...
- Hell Freezes Over: Fudan University in China Seek...
- Group Shows Cruelty of Zoos Has No Boarders: Prot...
- Asian Elephants Used In the Ringling Brothers and ...
- Florida Fish and Wildlife Commission Will Decide W...
- In Indian Zoos, Life Can Be Brutal and Short: Visi...
- Thai Government Under Fire For Zoo Trading: Change...
- A Call to Action: University Of Wisconsin-Madison ...
- The Staff of the GEARI Blog Will Re Post in a Few ...
-
▼
June
(70)
No comments:
Post a Comment