Wow, to not even go ahead with a common sense bill against cruelty makes you wonder why. Do they actually like cruelty?
Article:
Animal cruelty bill lacks teeth, say rights groups
http://www.canada.com/vancouversun/news/story.
html?id=58c89141-0a7d-4f73-8589-721c21d8f89e&k
=92219&p=1
Joel Kom
CanWest News Service; Ottawa Citizen
Wednesday, August 30, 2006
OTTAWA - The Conservative government has decided against re-introducing a Liberal bill from the last Parliament that would have modernized 19th century definitions of animal cruelty a decision that has angered animal-rights groups who lobbied to pass the bill for the past seven years.
The government will instead support a Liberal senator's bill, known as S-213, that focuses mostly on increasing fines and jail terms for animal cruelty offences, a spokesman for Justice Minister Vic Toews said Tuesday.
The Conservatives won't re-introduce the last Parliament's legislation, which itself was the fourth version of an animal-cruelty bill dating back to 1999, because it wasn't part of the party's platform, Mike Storeshaw said.
''S-213 is an approach we'd support,'' he said. ''We think the (penalties) that exist are too low and S-213 is a good way of handling it.''
The Senate bill, introduced in April by Liberal Senator John Bryden, would raise the maximum jail term to five years for indictable offences, higher than the current two-year maximum. The bill would also raise the maximum fine from the current $2,000 to $10,000 and allow judges to impose a lifetime ban on animal ownership for anyone convicted of animal cruelty.
Those penalties were all included in the last Parliament's legislation, which died last year after the election was called.
But the big difference, animal-rights groups said, was the parliamentary bill modernized definitions of animal cruelty that hadn't been updated since the first such law was passed in 1892. While some minor changes were made in the 1950s, they said, the Senate bill lets most of the 19th-century rules live on. For example, crimes against animals are considered property offences.
''The most unfortunate development around the whole debate ... is the introduction of Senator Bryden's bill,'' said Shelagh MacDonald, program director for the Ottawa-based Canadian Federation of Humane Societies, adding she was "enormously disappointed" with the Conservative plan.
MacDonald said the Senate bill fails to lower the high threshold that demands prosecutors prove someone intended to neglect animals, something the parliamentary bill would have done. The threshold came into play, MacDonald said, when a judge acquitted a Saskatchewan farmer charged with starving more than 30 sheep to death because the judge didn't feel the farmer intended to starve the animals.
The Senate bill would also not extend the law's protection to wild or unowned animals.
''If you can't convict to begin with, what difference does it make if the penalties are larger or smaller?'' said Cele Partap, a spokeswoman for the Toronto-based World Society for the Protection of Animals Canada.
Some had criticized the last parliamentary legislation for its potential to spark lawsuits from overzealous animal-rights groups who, they said, would go as far as making hunting and fishing illegal. Partap called that a ''radical statement,'' saying anything already lawfully regulated such as hunting and fishing would have been unaffected by the parliamentary bill.
That bill had, in various incarnations, been kicking around Parliament since 1999, yet it was never passed either because of an election call or because the parliamentary session ended. Storeshaw said he couldn't comment on animal-rights groups' specific concerns, only to say the government supported the Senate bill.
Brian Murphy, the Liberals' associate justice critic, said he was ''relatively receptive'' to the Conservatives' plans to back the Senate bill despite his preference to re-introduce the old legislation. But, he added, MPs would have the chance to make amendments to the Senate bill before it would become law, something his party would ''absolutely'' look at.
Ottawa Citizen
GEARI (the Group for the Education of Animal - Related Issues) is a non-profit educational group dedicated to assisting you in your search for information on animal rights-related issues, the environment and human health. Your reference source for animal rights information. Visit us at our web site at http://www.geari.org. Follow us on Facebook and Twitter, or Syndicate us via RSS.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Search for More Content
Custom Search
Past Articles
-
▼
2006
(726)
-
▼
August
(49)
- Jackie Chan Calls Out China on its Heartless Natur...
- Contracted Companies Continue Massive Seal Clubbin...
- Canadian Government Decides Against Introducing a ...
- Greed and Vanity Still Strong: Fur Makes Big Come...
- Activists Ask Israel's Teva Pharmaceuticals to Sev...
- Pittsburgh Woman Sentenced to Three Months in Jail...
- Like Giving a Junky Free Drugs: Leasing Elephants...
- Group Seeks to Build One-of-a-Kind Museum Protesti...
- Even Though No Law Requires Cosmetic Ingredients a...
- After Witnessing Horrifying Animal Abuse, Women De...
- Carson and Barnes Circus Again Questioned For Repe...
- Ben & Jerry’s Ice Cream Again at Root of Animal Cr...
- New Book Traces Historical and Philosophical Roots...
- California Law Would Require Pet Shops to Abide by...
- Editorial Exposes Truth Behind Iditarod: Dogs Mere...
- Citizens Raise Awareness to Use of Animals in Phar...
- Which Is Worse: China Massacring 50,000 Dogs Or U....
- Bill Put Forth In California That Would Make It a ...
- Illegal Wildlife Trade Destroying Species in Asia:...
- New Study: Majority of People in India Actually Ea...
- People in Vancouver, BC Celebrate 23rd Annual Anim...
- Even On Heels of Beyond-Disgusting Dog Slaughter, ...
- A Detailed Look into the Disgusting World of Dog F...
- A Look at Greyhound Racing; Why It’s Just Plain Ab...
- Swedish Animal Rights Group Questions the Use of A...
- Groups Attending To and Rescuing Animals Abandoned...
- Humane Society of the United States Will Give Chin...
- More On Chinese Killing Of 54,429 Dogs via Clubbin...
- Lincoln Park Zoo in Chicago Pays Small Fine for De...
- More on Suffering and Plight of Abandoned Animals ...
- Mulesing Sheep: What Is Mulesing? Is New Alterna...
- Group in California Puts Forth Bill to Limit Tethe...
- 150 Pigs Die in Transport from Ohio to Mexico: Wh...
- Provision in Pension Reform Act Stops Practice of ...
- Senate Passes Version of Pets Evacuation and Trans...
- In Response to Brutal, Unnecessary, Mass Dog Killi...
- Cruel China Plans Another Large Dog Cull: Many Wi...
- The Farm Animal Stewardship Purchasing Act: A Lit...
- No More Shark Fin Soup for NBA Star Yao Ming and 2...
- Activists in Korea Challenge Traditional Practice ...
- Report From the 2006 International Animal Rights G...
- Two Teen Girls Who Wrapped Cat In Plastic, Kicked ...
- Animal Testing Giant Covance Welcomed To Chandler,...
- Group of Teens in Britain Throws Cat from Fifth Fl...
- 58 Rare Animals Will Be Sent From Their Natural En...
- Information On Three Groups That Are Fighting To S...
- Cruel China Continues its Heartless Path: 50,546 ...
- Dean Foods, Owner of Horizon Organic Dairy Product...
- Even Meat Eaters See the Politics Behind Preventin...
-
▼
August
(49)
No comments:
Post a Comment