This article provides a few additional points about the proposed Horse slaughter legislation. In particular, it shows what it is and what it is not. For one, it is not an outright ban on slaughter or horses. Instead, it would ban horse slaughter for human consumption. It would also ban the shipment of horses to Canada or Mexico for slaughter.
It also clearly shows how fierce the opposition is. And as would be suspected, this is mainly money and political interests who instead look to rhetoric and money as excuses to continue this horrifying practice.
Here are a few paragraphs taken from the article below. They provide a summation of the important points.
Pickens said nearly all thoroughbreds, Arabians, quarter horses and wild mustangs sent to the plants are healthy young horses that he said the USDA has said are in "good to excellent" condition. He questioned why the state allows foreign countries, that he said pay little taxes, to slaughter American horses for consumption abroad.
"They should slaughter their own horses, not American horses," he said.
Congress tried to end the slaughter of horses last year by overwhelmingly approving legislation eliminating funding of Agriculture Department horse meat inspectors. But USDA is offering inspections on a fee-for-service basis to the plants.
The proposed legislation does not ban the slaughter of horses outright. Instead it bans shipping, transportation, delivery, receiving, buying or selling or donating of horses for slaughter for human consumption, putting it under the jurisdiction of the House Energy and Commerce Committee. The bill also would prevent sending horses from the U.S. to Canada or Mexico to be slaughtered.
Sweeney said he took that route because the Agriculture Committee has sat on previous legislation seeking to ban the horse slaughter and not given it a hearing.
The full Energy and Commerce Committee's scheduled a vote on the bill on Wednesday.
The House Agriculture Committee plans to consider and vote on the legislation on Thursday.
Article:
Texas lawmaker ends support for ban on horse slaughter
http://www.chron.com/disp/story.mpl/metropolitan/4072150.html
By SUZANNE GAMBOA
Associated Press
WASHINGTON — Supporters of a ban on horse slaughter lost a valuable congressional ally today but hoped for a boost from Texas oil tycoon T. Boone Pickens joining their cause.
Energy and Commerce Committee Chairman Joe Barton, R-Texas, said in the first hearing on a proposal on the divisive issue that he no longer supports legislation aimed at ending the slaughter of horses in the United States for consumption overseas.
Barton said he previously supported the bill sponsored by fellow Republican U.S. Reps. John Sweeney of New York and Ed Whitfield of Kentucky, but dropped his support after learning more about it.
"The agriculture community and rural America just is totally against the bill," he explained in a hearing break.
Pickens, a major Republican contributor, chastised his own state for being home to two horse slaughter plants. The third is in Illinois.
"This is a black eye on our state and nation that demands action," Pickens, of Dallas, told the panel.
Pickens said nearly all thoroughbreds, Arabians, quarter horses and wild mustangs sent to the plants are healthy young horses that he said the USDA has said are in "good to excellent" condition. He questioned why the state allows foreign countries, that he said pay little taxes, to slaughter American horses for consumption abroad.
"They should slaughter their own horses, not American horses," he said.
Congress tried to end the slaughter of horses last year by overwhelmingly approving legislation eliminating funding of Agriculture Department horse meat inspectors. But USDA is offering inspections on a fee-for-service basis to the plants.
The bill has 201 co-sponsors. Republican leaders have scheduled a vote for Sept. 7.
But opposition is fierce. The hearing on the bill stretched over about three hours and had to move to a larger room because of interest. Witnesses' comments were met with applause and gasps from some attending the hearing.
"This legislation is woefully inadequate, emotionally misguided and fails to serve the best interest of the American horse and horse owner," said Virginia Republican U.S. Rep. Bob Goodlatte, who chairs the House Agriculture Committee.
Dick Koehler, vice president of Beltex Corp., owner of a Fort Worth-based horse slaughter plant, urged lawmakers not to eliminate an entire industry, "just because animal rights activists find the product of this law abiding, tax paying legitimate business to be distasteful."
The proposed legislation does not ban the slaughter of horses outright. Instead it bans shipping, transportation, delivery, receiving, buying or selling or donating of horses for slaughter for human consumption, putting it under the jurisdiction of the House Energy and Commerce Committee. The bill also would prevent sending horses from the U.S. to Canada or Mexico to be slaughtered.
Sweeney said he took that route because the Agriculture Committee has sat on previous legislation seeking to ban the horse slaughter and not given it a hearing.
The full Energy and Commerce Committee's scheduled a vote on the bill on Wednesday. The House Agriculture Committee plans to consider and vote on the legislation on Thursday.
Divisions in the issue are not neat. They split members of the same party, horse associations, veterinarians and others and create unusual coalitions such as in the case of Pickens, who is on the same side as animal rights activists.
Supporters of the ban said horses are mistreated and abused when they are sent to horse plants by being shipped in inhumane conditions and are sometimes alive when they are being slaughtered. In addition, they say horses in this country have iconic status and are not raised for food.
"Would we ever serve a bald eagle in this country?" Sweeney asked.
But opponents say horses are euthanized humanely before they are slaughtered, their transport is heavily regulated and would suffer a worse death of starvation and neglect if slaughter was eliminated.
"Where do you get the money to foot the bill?" asked U.S. Rep. Tim Murphy, R-Pa.
GEARI (the Group for the Education of Animal - Related Issues) is a non-profit educational group dedicated to assisting you in your search for information on animal rights-related issues, the environment and human health. Your reference source for animal rights information. Visit us at our web site at http://www.geari.org. Follow us on Facebook and Twitter, or Syndicate us via RSS.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Search for More Content
Custom Search
Past Articles
-
▼
2006
(726)
-
▼
July
(57)
- British Government Takes Part in Making US Laws: ...
- Whales and Seals Washing Up On Shores of New Jerse...
- Heat Wave Leading To Death of Farm Animals: Next ...
- Group in Lebanon Continues To Rescue Abandoned Ani...
- A Philippine-Based Activist Flies To Beirut, Leban...
- House Committee On Agriculture Voted Overwhelmingl...
- Cruelty of Indian Leather Industry Causes Liz Clai...
- Horse Slaughter Ban Proceeds: Clears House Energy...
- Oakland Woman Charged With Felony Animal Abuse for...
- More on US Horse Slaughter Legislation: Important ...
- Brave Group Stays to Care For Animals Left Behind ...
- Texas Oil Billionaire T. Boone Pickens Supports Le...
- Editorial Exposes Politics Behind Obstruction of I...
- Bird Dies Excruciating Death: Left In Hot Car Whil...
- Jockey in England Vents His Anger at His Horse by ...
- Numbers from England Show That Animal Testing Hits...
- Ridiculous Internet Hunting Banned in Rhode Island
- Warmer Waters Due To Global Warming Disrupt Pacifi...
- Study: Tigers on the Brink of Extinction: Many Al...
- University of Hawaii Fined For Deaths of Dolphins ...
- Teenagers in South Africa Who Calculatingly Tortur...
- Follow Up From Post on US Military Forcing Evacuee...
- US Military Orders Evacuees from Lebanon to Leave ...
- Idiocy Bureaucracy: European Union Rules Prevent A...
- South African Teens Torment Mouse with Lit Cigaret...
- HSUS Draws Attention to Massive Shark Killing Tour...
- Site Provides Summation of Animal Rights News in E...
- US Heat Wave Killing Even Farm Animals: A Battle ...
- Group in Seattle Makes Reasonable Request to Have ...
- Hell Freezes Over: US House Approves Polar Bear Pr...
- Noted Class B Dog And Cat Dealer C.C. Baird Convic...
- Movement Continues To Reclassify Companion Animals...
- In Vitro or Lab-Grown Meat: Hope of the Future?
- Namibia Joins the Likes of Cruel Canada: Begins M...
- Thieves Targeting Zoos and Safari Parks to Supply ...
- 6000 Year Old Pronghorn Antelope Migration Route i...
- Juicemaker Tahitian Noni International Conducts An...
- Burger King Threatens to Sue Small Vegetarian Snac...
- Those New Shoes or New Soccer Ball May be Made fro...
- Non-Animal Drug Testing Method: Biochip Allows Sc...
- Monitoring Of Wolves in Wilderness Areas Again On ...
- New Book by Three Leading Pioneers – Decamp, Singe...
- Dark Water Rising: The Truth About Hurricane Katr...
- African Grey Parrot: Trade Is Driving Them to Exti...
- Commentary: Dog Tracks Horse Tracks Should Report...
- Britain's Frogs and Toads Face Threat of Extinctio...
- The True Life of the Duck Raised For Slaughter or ...
- Canadian Zoos Under Fire for Animal Neglect and Abuse
- New Measure in New York Could Provide The Same Cou...
- Elephant Trading Blockade in Thailand Leads To Big...
- Spain’s “Running of the Bulls” to Start in Two Day...
- Freeganism, Couchsurfing and Freecycling: A Synop...
- Ballot Initiative in Arizona to Increase Size of A...
- Facts: The Environmental Benefits of Vegetarianism
- Tourists Urged to Boycott Dolphin Parks and “Swim ...
- Group Files Case in Indian Supreme Court Against t...
- Group has Sent Urgent Letter to King Abdullah II O...
-
▼
July
(57)
No comments:
Post a Comment